Comments (3) | Posted by Nine on September 21, 2010
The one about Kenny McKinley
Posted in: Uncategorized
With the surprising and senseless death of Kenny McKinley in Denver this week, a simmering debate has taken one more step toward raging out of control. Lately sports writers and retired athletes wearing bad suits on ESPN have been spending a lot of time talking about concussions, especially amongst football player. Athletes have gotten so big and fast and strong that violence on the field has far outpaced the evolution of football safety equipment along with the evolution of knee ligaments.
Already Sports Illustrated and all manner of bloggers have posed the question of McKinley’s concussion history. Odds are every football player has suffered through a few concussions, even if a few mild ones may have gone undiagnosed along the way. Odds are just about everyone has suffered through a concussion or two at some point. At least I hope I’m not the only one haphazardly banging my head off every available hard surface.
The new theory on concussions says a history of concussions possibly leads to an increased risk of suicide and general insane behavior. There’s a long list of cases to support this theory, which is gaining steam by the day.
Former Philadelphia Eagle Andre Waters committed suicide in 2006. A study on his brain revealed the tissue had degenerated to the point it became similar to that of a man in his 80s rather than a 43-year-old professional athlete.
It’s called chronic traumatic encephalopathy. Owen Daniels, a University of Pennsylvania football player, committed suicide in April. He too showed signs of CTE due to a history of concussions.
The man who first asked the concussion question is a former Harvard football player named Chris Nowinski. He went on to be a WWE wrestler for a few years before ultimately retiring because of concussions. His history of concussions left him battling migraines and depression. He spearheaded the efforts to research this. He acquired Andre Waters’ brain for research by doctors at the University of Pittsburgh.
The Pitt doctors also did research on two former Steelers players. Mike Webster died homeless and crazy of heart failure. His brain also showed the effects of numerous concussions. Terry Long’s brain showed the signs, too. He committed suicide in 2005.
Sadly, there are several other confirmed cases and several dozen cases of suicide and bizarre behavior where the brains of those involved were unable to be examined.
The theory hit the mainstream hard with the death of Andre Waters and the Chris Benoit murder-suicide. Benoit’s brain was examined at the University of West Virginia and their report said it resembled the brain of an 85-year-old Alzheimer’s patient.
This all seems like a lot of hard evidence that a history of concussions leads to an increased suicide risk, among many other possible complications.
Seeing as how I like to go against the grain, I’d like to raise another point. I’d like to point out a bunch of people who didn’t have the same concussion history as these various athletes, but people who did have one thing in common with the football players and rasslers.
Ray Combs was the host of Family Feud when I was a kid. After his time on the Feud was over, Ray Combs injured his spine rather than his head in a car crash and was left in constant pain for the rest of his life. From there proceeded to lose some businesses and most of his money along with his mind. In the end, he used his bedsheets to hang himself while being held in a hospital on a 72-hour suicide watch.
Dana Plato is another example. She was on Diff’rent Strokes and she was huge as a teenager. She had a long history of drug and alcohol problems and it finally caught up to her when she overdosed on Soma and Lortab at 34.
Hugh O’Connor was a stud on In The Heat of the Night. He was like a mini-Bubba. He survived Hodgkins Lymphoma as a teenager, but had long-lasting addiction problems after taking prescription pain pills and marijuana during his illness. He shot himself in 1995. He had cocaine in his blood at the time, but no history of concussions.
Those are three examples of people who didn’t have a concussion history, but did have some manner of notoriety and problems related to their own fame along with the same life struggles faced by millions of people everywhere.
Like the athletes, they were at least somewhat notable figures dealing with the pressure of that. Dana Plato took sleeping pills and pain pills and she died from it. Hugh O’Connor became addicted to prescription pain pills. Ray Combs suffered a severe spinal injury and relied on pain pills to make it through his daily life.
It stands to reason that maybe we should look into the fact that notable people kill themselves more often than us more anonymous masses.
On the other hand, it stands to reason that maybe pharmaceuticals have as much to do with it as concussions or fame. Think about your favorite musicians who killed themselves and all the actors I didn’t get to. Think about all the non-notable people who kill themselves. Think about people paying 10 dollars per pill to get their hands on Oxycontin. Think about all the football injuries and the surgeries…and the pain pills.
I’ll bring up Charles Rogers. The Lions drafted him #2 overall in the 2003 NFL draft. He got hurt, and he never made a successful comeback because he became addicted to the painkillers he took while recovering from his injuries.
Christopher Nowinski, the Harvard man who came up with this concussion theory, works in Boston…in pharmaceuticals.

